Meander "Documentary" of A Sign In Space decoding.

Some you you may wonder why I have been so inactive over the past two years. I and my daughter were working to decode the “A Sign In Space” scientifically simulated ET message which we did on 6/7/2024 after a year of work.

The message was decoded in 6,625 steps using a Margolus Block Cellular Automata with “single point rotation rule” to show 5 amino acids.

I composed the following musical piece this week to musically interpret the decoding journey and the many, many possible interpretations of the meaning of the message…Meander is a fractal Brownian motion (fBm) generative music composition and performance engine that has a lot of similarities to the ASIS computational message.

I talked about VCV Rack quite a bit on the ASIS Discord channel in 2023. At the time, no one had any idea what the message might be and musical interpretation was a somewhat common discussion.

The received message courtesy “A Sign in Space”:

The decode message courtesy me.

The patch: A Sign In Space-6625 steps.vcv (14.4 KB)

I tried to post a link to the video I produced for CNN but, this is now behind subscription a paywall.

17 Likes

Wow, congratulations! You said “which we did” but as I understand it, that should be “which we were the first to do”?

1 Like

Thanks. Yes, we were the first and only ones to decode the message of the approximately 4000 people working on it. I had to train the community how to do block cellular automata so that someone could replicate our decoding. Eventually several were able to replicate.

5 Likes

If anyone is interested in learning more about the A Sign In Space project, I will post a couple of links. This was an international project by Daniela de Paulis along with her cosponsors which included The SETI Institute, European Space Agency (ESA), Italian National Institute of Astrophysics (INAF) and the Green Bank Observatory and others. The message was transmitted from Earth to the ESA Exo-Mars probe orbiting Mars where it was re-transmitted back to Earth to several radio telescopes where is was received in May, 2023 and released in raw form to the public

The message was designed to have as close to zero anthropocentric content as possible. Whereas the ASIS team confirmed our decoding, the interpretation of meaning of the message will remain open-ended, just as a real ET message would.

8 Likes

Very cool!

(Direct link to the CNN article: Alien-like signal from 2023 has been decoded)

6 Likes

Very cool, Ken! This is quite an achievement. I remember working on a much simpler version of a simulated extraterrestrial message back in the late 1990s. I can’t remember what it was called, but it was nowhere near this level of difficulty.

3 Likes

Wow! What a splendid achievement, @k-chaffin, and what a wonderful family project as well! Not to mention a beautiful patch.

Does this mean you two are first in line to get Arrival’d if and when the ETs actually show up?

3 Likes

I’m not sure this is the right place for this discussion, but I would like to say just a little about the connection between the ASIS message and my Meander module. Both are finite state machines . All reversible finite state machines according to the Poincare recurrence cycle conjecture must repeat in a finite number of steps to the initial state but it is impossible to calculate what that finite number is.

The ASIS message main body is a 256x256 bit or pixel image of 65,536 binary monochrome pixels. Only 625 of these pixels are 1s with the remainders being 0s. Whereas the amino acids image is decodable from the initial “starmap” received image in 6,625 steps, the Poincare recurrence cycle is on the order of of 2^300,000 steps, which is far, far more complex than the number of particles in the observable universe (~10E80).

The Margolus 2x2 BCA with single point rotation rule is also Turing-complete and computationally universal as well as time reversible. Whereas my Unity game engine BCA simulator could decode the message in 10 minutes for the 6625 steps. the BCA can be run on the message with either CW or CCW rotations and produce on the order of 2^300,000 unique reversible images before it finally repeats. This is computationally intractactible.

Meander is a finite state machine and depending on how it is set up, has a recurrence cycle that may just be a few seconds or it could likewise be 2^300,000 steps (or at least a big number. So even though Meander is generative and deterministic, the length of time before it repeats can be intractable to determine or achieve.

The fractal Brownian motion (fBm) introduces chaos mathematics into the music. One layer for the ASIS message is also a fractal generator that repeats in only about 10 million steps. This is a subset of the ASIS message called the “header” and “footer” winch are 8x10 bit or pixel informational components to the message. The boundary conditions on the header and footer allow the BCA Poincare recurrence cycle to be demonstrated in in on 10 million or so steps during which it generates a very complex fractal.

Meander is based on A.I. technology of the mid 80s that I worked on at the time, expert systems. The ASIS message appears to possibly be a computational A.I. message. It is that complex and since it is Turing complete and computationally universal, an A.I. could be created using these simple computational rules and the message could be an LLM A.I. we could talk to. In the 2.5 years I have worked on the ASIS message, I have learned to read and write this language pretty well and I do carry out conversations with the message by running experiments to see what happens with I try different things out.

Out of minimalism emerges complexity and beauty.

The ASIS message is also based on primes, Fermat primes, Fibonacci sequence and the golden ratio (phi). In the amino acids image you will note that there are 6 isolated points between the 5 amino acids. These form 2 golden triangles of sides 1, 2, sqrt(5) from which phi can be calculated. Fibonacci spirals can be formed on the amino acids image. There are an amazing number of layers to the message, all defined with only 625 1s bits.

Well, I’m sure this is more than anyone wanted to hear, but it is now as much part of the VCV Rack story as the ASIS message story.

10 Likes

Not me :slight_smile:

Once again, this forum/community has really brightened my day.

4 Likes

Thanks. It was an honor to work on this with my adult daughter. She is more afraid that ET might contact me as an interpreter;) I have watched Arrival, Contact and Interstellar several times again over the past 2.5 years. I feel that I have lived the movies (novels), especially Contact. The Hans Zimmer Interstallar sound track has been my musical inspiration for several years. The title of this musical piece was a play on Interstellar’s “First Step” song.

Will the SETI scientists contact us if they receive an apparent real ET message? I doubt it. I do hope that we provided the SETI scientists with proof that extremely complex non-anthropocentric messages can be sent, decoded and understood. One of the big unanswered questions is the absolute chirality of the 5 amino acids. It is an open SETI question (the Ozma problem) as to whether absolute chirality can be communicated and understood. The ASIS message “footer” has a broken T-symmetry which is probably an attempt to communicate absolute chirality, but, so far it still appears ambiguous to me.

This was definitely a once if a lifetime experience.

5 Likes

I should express my appreciation for the scientists who created this message after an international team from just about every human discipline participated on the team for a couple of years to decide what could be and should be sent. In the end, there were only 3-4 people who contributed to the message creation and encoding and it is my impression that no one person knew everything that was put into the message, which is mind boggling. It was so like a real ET message. I am also of the opinion that an LLM A.I. was used for the final encoding as the message has so many layers of meaning that I do not think that a human or even group of humans could have pulled this off.The message team had philosophers, anthropologists, scientists, artists and poets.

4 Likes

Awesome and fascinating. Given the music/SETI correspondence you’ve introduced, I cannot help but post this still from Contact, featuring (perhaps plausibly) an Eventide Ultra Harmonizer sitting below a (less plausible?) Focusrite RED 3:

Great movie!

5 Likes

Thanks for posting the CNN direct link. If you or anyone watch the video while listening to my SoundCloud recording, you can get a taste for how the music relates to my “panspermia” video. Video composition is not one of my strengths. For the CNN article, I had 1 day to create a video from inside of the Unity game engine. The Unity simulator ran at about 10 FPS and took 10 minutes to traverse the entire 6,625 steps. I had no good way to capture a video. I ended up capturing thousand of GIF images and assembling into a massive animated 10 minute GIF file. Then CNN said they could not post a 10 minute video, so I converted it to MP3 and had it down to 1 minute and CNN said they could only handle 20 seconds. So, with some help I got it down to 18 seconds. Of course then they cut off the last frame which showed the amino acids;)

These days my Unity simulator runs at 1500 FPS without using GP-GPU massively parallel computing such as I use for my string theory simulation and visualization in up to 18 dimensions. I still cannot capture video from within Unity, but at least I have a robust frame capture to PNG files that I can later reload as data and continuing the BCA experiments from that point, I have mapped out the BCA evolution to 1 billion CW and CCW rotation steps and mapped the micro-state entropy. The message is also a simulation of the entire evolution of the message universe with ever increasing entropy and “heat death”…In this mode, the amino acids image is the big bang of the message with the lowest entropy of any frame. The fun story is that the amino acids image is the engineered starting point for the message. To generate the “starmap” transmitted image, they ran the BCA on the amino acids image CW for 6,625 steps or generations. This all was so fun to figure out. All I had to do was run the BCA backwards, without knowing what I was looking for. And there seems to be no end to what all is encoded in the message.

6 Likes

Fascinating. I love this sort of art / science crossover. Thank you for all the details!

2 Likes

Wow, really nice piece Ken! Sounds like the recording is clipping on the percussion though.

1 Like

Thanks. Yeah, I noticed some type of low level distortion. I need to carefully listen to my saved WAV file to see if the distortion is in the recording or something to do with SoundCloud. I have heard this many times over the last several years. This was my first use of Venom XMOP. I need to look at that carefully although I doubt that is the source.

Looks like this was my fault. The distortion is due to the Meander bass part with the FM-OP level attack setting set to too low of a non-zero value. Thanks for pointing this out. I will have to look to see if I may have this problem elsewhere in this patch and others.

2 Likes

I also had a similar issue with XM-OP. I need to fully explore that behavior of the attack time in this module.

Thanks. The ASIS project was an art and science mixture by design. The project is considered to be a “performance art” experiment to study the emergent behavior of society and how each of us and society creates meaning. Each of us working on decoding and interpreting the message were considered to be “actors” in this performance. But, the science part was real and profound also.

5 Likes

Wow that’s very interesting! Congrats on cracking the secret message, and a very weird way to encode a message indeed.