First… Dave, this is flat-out fantastic! You absolutely captured the essence of the patch. Thank you for going through it and removing the cruft and mistakes.
I didn’t know you were working on it, so I began my own version last night and the first thing I noticed were the JI quantizers were waaaay off. It caused a radical deepening in the patch, especially with the absence of the arpeggio. I’m surprised it escaped me but I remember the patch update being the result of the late night session and with the JI accommodations, I can see how I missed it but I’m definitely looking forward to releasing an improved and corrected version.
It took me a minute to realize that with no .kbm file, the NSYTHI module defaults to C. I ended up with a transposition technique very similar to yours although I continued to use the NSYTHI module. That, and the Slime Child modules offered some octave transposition, I think. JI and Pythagorean scales are both scales I use for anything pretty and mostly diatonic so I appreciate the care in replicating the original sound. And I’m glad to have a better idea how to get the microtonal results I want with free modules.
I can see how I left the Stack modules around, I was experimenting with transposition and scale quantization a lot in the process. The use of only one of the Squinktronix Harmony out was intentional, I wanted to keep things very open but I like that module a lot! The 4 voice harmonies are impressive.
Also, I have to say I haven’t gone super deep into your collection of modules yet but the Knob 5 and VCA Mix 4 are completely essential, go-to modules for me. I think I had some important voltage realizations directly because of menus on those modules! I look forward to trying Logic and Benjolin Oscillator in particular but there’s a lot to choose from. For example, I didn’t know you had a harmonic/subharmonic module, which is great!
Regarding the patch, outside of the bass being maybe a tiny bit loud (and the original, too), I would like to release your patch in a zip with the original for my more or less final release of the patch on Patchstorage (AFAIK, my only other plans might be to do a proper mix and release on streaming but I would use the original patch for that). Regarding the challenge, I haven’t checked if they have any rules pertaining to collaboration but in the long run this version is great and the bass is growlier so it makes sense to keep everyone in the loop and update on Patchstorage, perhaps with a new video.
Thanks so much for sharing this!