This is related to the problem of ‘how do I get a sequencer to play the first step when the clock starts?’ That’s a problem I’ve always solved by not caring too much about sequencers starting any particular place
But this is a question that came up in a discussion of how to replicate Caterina Baribieri’s SOTRS sequences. The backbone of that piece is a 5 note sequence that rises in pitch, where the first note changes with each repetition. I solved that by using a @synthi “Dual Five Steps” module plus @jeremy 's JW Patterns module to do the division.
The catch with Patterns (and, as far as I know, all clock dividers) is that if you tell it to divide the clock by 5, it triggers on the 5th, 10th, 15th etc clock after reset.
It would be useful for dividers to have a ‘trigger on first clock’ mode, where divide by 5 would trigger on the 1st, 6th, 11th, 16th etc clock pulse.
This doesn’t matter in the case where you just want different clock divisors to cycle against each other and aren’t particular about how it turns out.
It’s ambiguous in @vortico’s response what “That Way” refers to.
Testing with scopes it appears:
Aradicity Clock Divider: Nth Divisor puts out trigger on first clock
Synthkit Clock Divider: Nth Divisor first pulse on Nth Clock.dividers.vcv (9.3 KB)
AS Rebit Trigger Seq/Clock Divider: " "
Autodafe Clock Divider: " "
JW Patterns: " "
If there are are more clock dividers than that they’re not tagged as “clock dividers”
Clocked will do 1 and 6 on a divide by 5 clock. The 1.1.1 version even has some handy new features about whether or not to reset on run or stop, and sending a 1ms pulse, which can be a lifesavers when trying to trigger multiple sequencers on the same beat in a reproducible manner.
Both ways are common, but “downbeat mode” is how I’d personally do it. I think the Doepfer A-160 also has a jumper in the back, but don’t quote me on that.
Downbeat mode seems more useful because a /4 divider for example will turn quarter notes 1, 2, 3, 4, 1, 2, 3, 4, … into whole notes 1, 1, 1, … I wouldn’t want to have whole notes on beat 2, 2, 2, … by default. If I wanted that, I’d intentionally use a clock delay module.
A context menu option is best for modules that already use upbeat mode. You don’t want to break patches that rely on upbeat behavior. You can even make downbeat mode the new default by checking the existence of a JSON setting.