What happened with the library screenshots?

Something is strange, if you look at the library, the screenshots all have a bit of Rack around them (PC) or the full Rack rails on the phone. And the module browser in Rack shows all recently updates modules with a yellow frame around them.

I already wrote to Support, just wonderung if you see the same issues or if it is just me?

Not just you. It had a white background a day or so ago. Wonder what it’ll look like tomorrow :slight_smile:

Looks like the site is in dark mode now too!

Just checked: the site and the library are fine. Note that only the “premium” modules are highlighted in yellow.

Not here they’re not. Chrome on Linux.

I only see yellow Add to Basket links for those I do not own and nothing special for those I do… MacOS arm64 Rack 2.6.6 here, both Chrome and Opera.

Support contacted me and it’s not a bug, it’s a feature. The idea is to have the modules sitting on rack rails in the library overview pages, matching the browser’s light or dark color theme for the rack background.

I am not convinced, but it is not my site.

The yellow box in the module browser marks favorite modules, I probabbly just never noticed, since I use light panels most of the time.

I find it an unfortunate design change. The web Library looks messier this way in my opinion. :frowning:

Certainly less readable. Like a graveyard or something.

Also to gabtiorbi:

Well, the free modules are “highlighted” in blue. So I don’t think that’s a problem exactly. I think the way it is… I guess we can call it “smartphonized” doesn’t look good and has no value for usual people using PCs. But it unintentionally(!) creates this situation when the percentage of blue highlight on free modules looks less significant when compared to whole line in yellow highlight. Wait. I’ll show it, so people would understand. That’s not the best example, because the free module here is huge. But…

So yeah. I think that’s the webdev cargo cult or something. Social media platforms and popular sites go with mobile-like design, cramping as much information as they can fit on little screens before it becomes unreadable. And it became a prominent style, or a ritual of this cargo cult, even for the sites that aren’t necessarily designed to be seen on little screens. Like here. So yeah, that’s my understanding of why it happened. It mimics the “popular” dense-info style designed for smartphones

Can you explain why you think the VCV Library design isn’t readable? The brand, name, description, tags, price, and screenshot are all portrayed in a balanced way within the available space. I think it looks great, and it’s the best design I could come up with in a few hours, but I always welcome specific feedback for improvement.

Sure, i’ll try! Well, first of all, I said “less readable”, not “isn’t readable”, so that’s what I will defend here. Also “and screenshot are all portrayed in a balanced way within the available space” - that absolutely misses the point of a screenshot provided, that was taken to illustrate that the comment I was responding to, wasn’t right, so I took a screenshot of a small portion of a screen.

Now, why it’s less readable. Here’s a wayback machine screenshot of the whole page with smaller modules

Here’s this same segment, more or less with new design

I don’t know what to tell you, man… Tags had a bad habit to disappear in the old design in order to prioritize the description. That’s not good, but that’s not your fault either. People write poems there, I don’t know why, but it pushes tags out of the space dedicated for module’s description.

Well, that’s not what I wanted to show with this screenshot though. You see how free it is? I think the way to describe it would be “luxurious” or something. It’s sparse, yeah, but that improves the readability of a page overall. The sparseness is created, because each module occupies a lot of screen space, the tags are big (when they are seen), so if you have a poor eyesight, like I do, it doesn’t strain your eyes as much as when you read different fonts sizes in the same box (and I am not saying that everyone should optimize their sites for poor eyesight, but that gives an idea that if I feel it, and you don’t, that doesn’t mean your eyes are happy with it). Right now it’s like 4 different sizes. Which 2 would make sense, of course, the header and the description. But the +Add is a different size, I feel like (that could be an effect of a padding + bold font though), and the tags have different font size too. Also the images are smaller now - therefore, less readable too. The boxes feel cramped and forced into some kind of graveyard, as I said before. It really feels like what you see on some sites optimized for mobile devices. Cramped, easy to scan though, but hard to read. I hope I conveyed the idea, why it’s less readable. I also don’t like the bottom right +Add button, but that could be just a subjective preference.

What I like about the new design though is that it forces the tags to appear. That’s helpful, I don’t like poems in the description, I rarely read them.

Maybe I misunderstood your earlier post. Are you saying that the old design was less readable? I would definitely agree with that, so we’re on the same page.

No. Sadly we are not on the same page… The new one is less readable. The old one was less scannable, I guess. The overall readability was better with the old one, but it had problems, not denying that at all. So, to make it absolutely clear, so that my ESL wouldn’t mess the things up: overall page right now is easier to parse, but harder to read. So it feels like a mobile phone screen… Or certain apps. The problem is older than that, of course, so if you want some old timey stuff instead of phone-optimized design, it’s something like this.

Same problem: trying to cramp everything onto one page, making people somewhat overwhelmed and straining your eyes.

The older design felt like… this, I guess

A lot of free space, but that makes you focus more on the items presented. It had flaws, as I said before, but it was much more readable. Less parseable though. Harder to scan, because the items were uneven, but each item was presented with luxury, like something valuable, I guess. And now it feels like… yeah, I already used all the good analogies.