Suzanne Ciani 4 Buchla patch setup and techniques in VCV

That exact question was the one bugging me all along this project: why? What was the intent of Buchla? Who even asked for this?! As an interface designer, this is so crazy to me that such a nerdy machine can be performance-oriented.

I was lucky enough to discuss the question with Suzanne and Ryan Gaston from the Buchla archive, and understanding how the 248 came to be was the missing piece I needed.

It all comes down to the Buchla 500: a 1971 (the first?) computer-controlled synth, with an integrated screen and a software “sequencer” of 64 channels, 128 stages each. All stages had properties that could be edited on screen: length, behavior, role in the sequence… (no Eurorack sequencer does that today with 64 ch).

The computer cost a fortune, same for the 16 in/24out cv converter … there might not have been more than 3 Buchla 500s ever made. So in 1974, Buchla was looking for a computer-less alternative to the concept: he made a huge module with 2 channels instead of 64, and 16 steps instead of 128. No computer, just tons of logic components, No screen, just switches instead of checkboxes on screen, and faders instead of entering values: the 248.

The 1975 Buchla catalog tells us a bit about his intent: almost all recommended systems feature a 248; some systems don’t even feature an envelope or sequencer other than the 248, but all of them feature the Source of Uncertainty. A way to read it would be: the MARF can take care of everything deterministic and has to be combined with the S.O.U. for randomness. This should explain the part of your question about the “staticness” of the MARF.

The CMOS logic components were brand new and unreliable. To his knowledge, there are no 248 units that ever work the way they should. Buchla hated this module after it crashed on him in a live performance, and as soon as micro-computers became available, Buchla discontinued the 248 (±12 ever made) and brought back the idea back into software with the Buchla 300 and its PATCH IV programming language.

So, voilà: the 248 is a “budget” hardware port of a super powerful software idea. One might understand how it must have been a downer for Buchla, and any engineer’s mind can see switch-based programming as a step back, but musicians understood that unlike any software, this switch-based tool is a great performance device, and we have to thank Ciani alone for that, as she probably was the only performance-oriented artist to use it. Her and Buchla had a very different understanding of the 248, and Ciani didn’t like the 250e (designed by Buchla in 2006 with all the features of the 248, different interface).

Overall, the magic is that the performance aspect is the unexpected byproduct of porting a software idea into a machine you can touch.

It’s worth mentioning that after a few days working with the 248t, one quickly understands it’s a great performance tool, but can feel that it wasn’t made for that: Ciani got into very hacky territories to get the most of it, and it really feels like one shouldn’t have to. There are tons of ways to keep the same “hands-on” pleasure while having some more obvious ways to perform. I think that any future 248-inspired module should be focused on that.

7 Likes

Around a dozen 248s were originally made? This shifts my appreciation of the 248 into “Unicorn” territory. Wow.

I’ll keep on chipping away at my interpretative ideas in VCV and Bitwig. One of the most brilliant compositional gems of Suzanne Ciani’s is the 4 sequences which are musically pleasing and complete regardless of how you scan through them (vertical arpeggio, scanned sequences which loop, jump, offset, or randomly voice). I have yet to create a cluster of notes which can flow and sound amazing regardless of how it is played.

1 Like

I think the possibilities offered by these four sequences alone are fantastic. I’ve already spent quite a bit of time playing with them. It’s also great to mix in the second voice and, for example, skip steps, or to transpose and modulate differently with the same sequence selection.

Karl

1 Like