I have this idea I wanted to bounce off people in this forum because it seems like it could be really fun if it could actually work.
It’s pretty simple: run a rack patch on a tiny embedded board that is in a guitar pedal enclosure.
There would be an audio input, an audio output, and maybe 2, 3, or 4 knobs on the pedal.
These hardware components would be integrated with the running patch, prob via dedicated modules that would be built as part of the project.
Does this seem feasible?
I’m an experienced software developer but don’t have a whole lot of experience with embedded development so it would potentially be a big learning experience for me if I decided to take this on.
The motivation for this idea is that I use a lot of pedals lately and would love to be able to have one that would allow me to leverage the vast library of rack modules for my experiments
Fun box. I have one, but it doesn’t get used a lot. Interface is frustrating. On your dream pedal, you would also want USB input so you can create patches in your preferred computer platform and load them easily onto the pedal.
Yeah that’s interesting. I only envisioned it loading a single patch that you send to the device over USB. Seems like this 4ms module provides a way to have a bunch of patches on a microsd card and then dynamically load them via a tiny UI on the module.
I would, if I decided to do this dream pedal project, prob favor that as a “deluxe” or “plus” edition of the device. The simpler and cheaper one would just have a single patch that is essentially going to load automatically anytime you power up the pedal
I’m guessing that would at least make the initial version simpler and be a good foundation to build something more complex on
In regards to the 4ms pedal linked above, which does bear a lot of similarity to the pedal idea, I wonder if anyone knows if there is a way to run vcvrack “headless” i.e. with no UI
Seems like this is a requirement to be able to run a patch on a device with no mouse, keyboard, monitor
I noticed this in the library the other day, no idea how it works and I haven’t tried it though:
I pretty much use my laptop as a guitar pedal with VCV. I suppose an actual pedal would be better for live use, but I like to make really complex effects patches, so if it only ran a few modules I probably wouldn’t be interested.
Guessing it would be pretty much the same as the 4ms thing, but pedal format instead Eurorack.
And furthermore, there is also a fork of VCV called Cardinal that was even ported to a guitar pedal. I think this one: MOD Duo - MOD Audio website
Anyways VCV plugins can run in headless mode, as that is how it works in VSTs. Although I’ve not tried to do any VCV-pedal stuff yet.
I can say that using the 4ms MetaModule with VCV plugins as an FX chain for guitar in-rack is quite fun. I use Ears as an input because it has a ton of gain.
This is great feedback. I tend to agree that the project might feel kind of pointless if it could only run simple patches with a couple modules. I also think that given the pedal form factor is usually very small i.e. limited real estate for UI elements like physical knobs and buttons on the device, limitations on the size or complexity of the patch the device would accept might kind of make sense unless a lot of the modules in the patch don’t need user input/control
Oh, I’m right there with you. At least one person has told me they’ve used my VCV modules on stage in performance, and I’d love to hear more of that for all of us.
The size and power requirements to run VCV may make the pedal form factor difficult for now, but if people are plugging away at it, the day may come. After all, the concept of simulating a bunch of modules on a desktop wasn’t all that tenable 10-15 years ago.
I do wonder if an interim solution might be to have a pedal that controls a laptop or small-form PC. Something like:
guitar passes audio to pedal
pedal passes control info (knob positions, switch positions) and the audio to the PC running headless Rack.
PC passes audio back to pedal
pedal passes audio to next pedal.
Sadly, I decided 40 years ago that my strengths lay more in software than hardware, so I can’t be of much help.